Girl power
02 Dec 2007 Leave a Comment
in 2007, kylie minogue, music, pop, popular music, Sugababes, top ten, UK charts, UK pop
Hello again! This week it’s all about the girls, again, as we review two big new albums by Kylie and the Sugababes. Important questions to be answered: is Kylie back on form after her recent personal struggles? And can the ’babes pull off yet another hit album? All will be revealed now…
Kylie Minogue – X
Unbelievably, it’s been four years since Kylie’s last studio album, and in a career spanning twenty years, this is only her tenth (hence the name). Though we all know why she’s been away for four years (which I don’t think would be appropriate for discussion here), four years feels like a heck of a long time, and for this reason alone any new Kylie album was bound to be a major event in the world of pop. As soon as the press release about X went out, I’m sure many of us couldn’t stop ourselves from counting the minutes until November 26th. I know I couldn’t!
First single ’2 hearts’ is, let’s face it, a cracking opener. It’s quite comforting to hear a performer who’s been around for a long time be daring and confident at the same time. The comparisons to Goldfrapp are obvious and, I daresay, a little lazy. Yes, it’s heavily influenced by glamrock, but I think it’s poppy enough to become a true Kylie classic. There are, pleasingly, quite a few Kylie classics waiting in the wings on this album. Fade To Grey-influenced ‘Like A Drug’ sets an electronic disco tone; ‘Sensitized’ takes Kylie right back to her Confide In Me era, which is extremely thrilling to hear; upcoming single ‘Wow’ is like Love At First Sight times 10. With X Kylie has definitely gone back to the uplifting, camp disco sound of Light Years and Fever that only she does really well.
The move away from the more instrumental, R’n'B sound of Body Language is surprisingly welcome, although track no.12, ‘Nu-di-ty’, is Kylie at her minimal, breathy best. It’s not instantly easy on the ear, and it is rather a reminder that when Kylie is stripped of the camp showtunes, there isn’t much to her singing voice. The heavy use of vocoders on ‘Speakerphone’ doesn’t help matters here.
Above all, though, X could easily be claimed as Kylie’s return to form. The formula hasn’t been messed with too much, but it has been pushed forward just enough to keep it up to date. It’s also good to hear the pace slowed down a bit on ‘No More Rain’, ‘All I See’ and final track ‘Cosmic’; we like serious Kylie (as long as she’s not too serious!)
I hereby declare this album an 8 out of 10. Enjoy!
Sugababes – Change
They’re an easy target for jokes these days, given the high profile line-up changes that they’ve seen over the years, but with the release of ‘Change’ they’ve now clocked up as many studio albums as they’ve had members, and in my book that’s pretty impressive for a group of women all under the age of 25. What’s also good about this album is that it is the first to entirely feature the vocals of newest member Amelle, who seems to better fill the shoes of Mutya every day.
It gets off to such a promising start. Their biggest hit to date, ‘About You Now’ is about as rocky as bubblegum pop gets; the mesh of drum ‘n’ bassy beats with heavy bass guitars is already a 2007 classic. ‘Never Gonna Dance Again’ is not, thankfully, an updated version of Careless Whisper, it’s just a dancey Sugababes-by-numbers tune that would probably go down very well on a dancefloor in Macclesfield on Friday night. Other album highlights include ‘Back Down’, possibly the sexiest ‘babes track to date, which is actually pretty darn good; and ’3 Spoons of Suga’, another funky floorfiller that mixes psychedelic beats with dirty trombones and a killer bassline.
Otherwise, it’s all a bit downhill from there. Next single, ‘Change’, is all right; it hardly catches the ear though, mainly because it has no melody. ‘Back When’ is too sickly sweet to be interesting; ‘Mended By You’ is a bit too Bleeding Love for my liking, and ‘Open The Door’ sounds scarily like Lutricia McNeal’s Ain’t That Just The Way, not in a good way either.
I would love to have been more enthralled by this album, but I wasn’t. So for that reason I’m giving it 5 out of 10. I’m sorry, Sugababes, but you will really have to try harder next time.
In TV this week I’ve been avidly following the progress of ‘I’m A Celebrity…’, mainly because I was so desperate to see 
Christopher Biggins win. When he finally did, it was surprisingly touching. Not just because he entertained solidly throughout the show, but because any mainstream reality show being won by an openly gay man is pretty special. I’ve loved his face when Ant ‘n’ Dec read the result out; I also loved it when his boyfriend came running towards him on the bridge at the end. How sweet!
I missed X Factor yesterday, but I wasn’t surprised to hear that Hope have been shipped out, so to speak. In the end, it looks like Phoebe couldn’t continue to carry the ‘group’ after all. I had a soft spot for them in the beginning, but I do think that the competition was too good this year. And it doesn’t help that the market for girl groups in pop is not what it once was - sadly.
So, Leona Lewis is number one once again with Bleeding Love. I don’t hate the song but I wish it wasn’t so bleeding Americanized. If Mr Cowell took a look at the British acts who’ve actually been successful across the pond in recent years, he might notice that they all had a bit of personality and uniqueness, rather than just being blatant copies of what the Americans had been churning out for years.
Rant over, for this week!!
Next week, I give Shayne Ward’s latest ‘Breathless’ a listen. Wish me luck…
